{"id":"arxiv/2604.16544","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.16544","tags":["physics.acc-ph","hep-ph","physics.optics","quant-ph"],"score":0,"title":"Comment on \"Angular momentum dynamics of vortex particles in accelerators''","domain":"physics.acc-ph","source":"arxiv","authors":["S. S. Baturin"],"reviews":0,"subject":"physics.acc-ph","summary":"We comment on Ref.[D. Karlovets, D. Grosman, and I. Pavlov, Phys. Rev. Lett. 136, 085002 (2026)], which proposes a BMT-like equation for the mean kinetic orbital angular momentum (OAM) of vortex particles in accelerator fields and draws spin-like conclusions about depolarization, resonances, and control. We show that the proposed closure is not generally valid even at the mean-value level. In the authors' own homogeneous-field model, Eq.(8) already makes $\\langle L_z\\rangle$ depend on the packet second moment $\\langle ρ^2\\rangle(τ)$; for an exact family of breathing Landau/LG packets this…","category":"research","comments":0,"disputed":false,"division":"physics","mentions":0,"discussed":0,"published":"2026-04-17","reactions":{}}