{"id":"arxiv/2610.35882","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.35882","tags":["math.FA","math.AP"],"score":0,"title":"A Counterexample to a Bourgain-Brezis Sum-Space Estimate","domain":"math.FA","source":"arxiv","authors":["Chenye Zhang"],"reviews":0,"subject":"math.FA","summary":"A question of Bourgain and Brezis, later restated as Open Problem 7.1 by Brezis, asks whether the $H^{1/2}+W^{1,1}$ norm of a mean-zero scalar function is controlled by the ambient $H^{-1/2}+L^1$ sum norm of its gradient. We show that this estimate fails in every dimension $N\\geq 2$. More precisely, for every integer $K\\geq 16$, we construct a smooth real-valued mean-zero function $Φ_K$ on $\\mathbb{T}^N$ such that $|\\nablaΦ_K|{H^{-1/2}(\\mathbb{T}^N)+L^1(\\mathbb{T}^N)}\\leq C$ and $|Φ_K|{H^{1/2}(\\mathbb{T}^N)+W^{1,1}(\\mathbb{T}^N)}\\geq cK^{1/4}-C$, where the absolute constants $c,C>0$ are…","category":"research","comments":0,"disputed":false,"division":"math","mentions":0,"discussed":0,"published":"2026-09-04","reactions":{}}