{"id":"arxiv/2611.00981","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.00981","tags":["math.PR","physics.hist-ph"],"score":0,"title":"Invariant universal averages and Bertrand's paradox: a response to Shackel","domain":"math.PR","source":"arxiv","authors":["Massimiliano Sassoli de Bianchi"],"reviews":0,"subject":"math.PR","summary":"In 2014, with D. Aerts we proposed a solution to the hard problem of Bertrand's paradox by means of a universal average over different ways of randomizing an entity. In his recent monograph, N. Shackel raises objections concerning the approximation by cellular densities, the restrictions used in their construction, the apparently trivial limit of their averages, the choice of a second-order probability law, and the dependence of the result on the naming of chords. We revisit these objections using the invariance-based formulation of the universal average. The first objection is well taken,…","category":"research","comments":0,"disputed":false,"division":"math","mentions":0,"discussed":0,"published":"2026-10-31","reactions":{}}