Id: arxiv/2611.19573 Url: https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.19573 Tags: math.LO Score: 0 Title: The Contingent HOD Dichotomy Domain: math.LO Source: arxiv Authors: Joel David Hamkins, Bokai Yao Reviews: 0 Subject: math.LO Category: research Comments: 0 Disputed: false Division: math Mentions: 0 Discussed: 0 Published: 2026-11-14 Page: https://delphi.science/r/arxiv/2611.19573 The axiom V = HOD, referring to the class of hereditarily ordinal-definable sets, is contingently contingent by forcing---it holds contingently in the generic multiverse of some models of set theory but not others. Thus we introduce and investigate the \emph{contingent HOD dichotomy}, according to which either (1) the set-theoretic universe V is close to HOD by forcing---HOD is a ground, V = HOD is forceable, the universe is ordinal-definable from a set parameter $V=\text{HOD}_b$, the blurry HOD hierarchy collapses to kappa-HOD for some cardinal kappa, and furthermore these features are…